Hello dear
Welcome To The Red Mill Inn & Pizza
The Red Mill Inn & Pizza, located in Brookfield, WI, is a charming dining destination offering a delightful selection of pizzas, pastas, and entrees. Renowned for its cracker crust pizza and standout garlic bread, the restaurant prides itself on a welcoming atmosphere complemented by friendly service. Guests rave about dishes like the Lobster Mac & Cheese and Fried Chicken Parmesan, highlighting the consistency in quality and taste. The patio seating adds to the experience, making it a perfect spot for gatherings. Whether you're in the mood for classic Italian or comforting American fare, The Red Mill Inn & Pizza delivers with flair and heart.
About
The Red Mill Inn & Pizza
Welcome to The Red Mill Inn & Pizza, a delightful culinary gem nestled in Brookfield, Wisconsin. This charming locale at 1005 S Elm Grove Rd combines a cozy atmosphere with a menu that showcases the best of Italian comfort food. Whether you're in the mood for a pizza party with friends or a casual dinner date, The Red Mill Inn is ready to cater to your every craving.
The highlight of this beloved establishment is undoubtedly its specialty pizzas. With options like the Vuoto Margherita and the intriguing Pepperoni Pickle Pizza, there's something for every palate. As customer Kathy Clancy attests, the cracker crust pizza is consistently praised for its excellence, making it a must-try for any pizza lover. Adding to the experience, their acclaimed garlic bread has earned a reputation as one of the best around.
If you prefer something different than pizza, the menu also features an array of tempting pasta dishes. From the rich and hearty Braised Beef Short Rib Ravioli to the flavorful Cio E Pepe, each plate is crafted with care to ensure a satisfying meal. And let’s not forget about the seasonal items, like Lobster Eggs Benedict from their brunch menu, which have impressed guests time and again.
Service at The Red Mill Inn is an equally delightful part of the dining experience. As noted in customer reviews, the staff, including Phil and Rosie, go above and beyond to ensure your visit is memorable. The friendly, accommodating service makes everyone feel at home, contributing to the restaurant's warm and inviting atmosphere. Diners love gathering on the patio during warmer months, enhancing the enjoyment of their meals with a touch of fresh air.
In conclusion, whether you're after a classic marinara for your spaghetti, a rich plate of ravioli, or a creative pizza combination, The Red Mill Inn & Pizza stands out as a dining destination. With exceptional food, friendly service, and a welcoming ambiance, it truly embodies the essence of comfort food done right. Visit them today at +1 262-599-8900—it might just become your new favorite spot!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Cracker crust pizza is always excellent along with one of the best garlic breads we have ever had! The wait staff and bartenders are all friendly and fun! Love sitting out on the patio too! ”
“ Last week we had a larger group come in for a pizza party. Due to circumstances it was somewhat last minute. Phil was so accommodating, going above and beyond to make sure we were taken care of. Rosie, our server, did an excellent job, everyone was very pleased. The bartender was great also! Food and service 10/10. ”
“ andy Old Fashioned Sweet was tasty and a generous pour—just how it should be. The fish fry wasn’t quite as good as last time; a little overdone tonight, but still decent overall. Crust pizza had an interesting sauce flavor that worked well. Solid spot with a cozy feel—just hoping the fish is back to form next time. ”
“ My wife and I found a dining gem by accident. During construction on Sunnyslope Road, a detour took us past the Red Mill restaurant. We found the atmosphere to be pleasant. The restaurant is always clean and friendly. The food is excellent, great pizza, garlic bread and we LOVE the Italian salad!!! The service is outstanding and Phil always provides us with a warm welcome and excellent service! ”
“ We went there for Mothers Day for their brunch menu. I had Lobster Eggs Benedict, which was delicious. Hubby had prime Rib,Potatoe pancake Eggs Benedict, he said it was outstanding. Our Son had Lobster Mac & Cheese which also was delicious. Our Bloody Mary’s were served with a slice of pizza on top. Wonderful food, drinks and service . Had a wonderful time ”
“ Completely in love with this little gem. The pizza is the best I’ve had in a very long time. Family atmosphere and sports are available with the best staff in the area. I love the thin crust pizza with jalapenos and pepperoni. Everything is made in house with the freshest ingredients. I highly recommend. ”
“ Nice relaxed atmosphere and really good food and drinks. The pizza was top-notch. Kids loved the food as well. Definitely glad we stopped. ”
“ We stopped in to have their fish dinner. I had half baked/fried cod and my wife had all baked cod. We both really enjoyed the fish, the fried cod was excellent. We also had the potato pancakes, which had a slightly sweet taste and were also really good. It’s an older establishment and look every bit of that statement. Our table and seats were clean and so was the rest of the seating area. I’d recommend trying their fish dinners and plan to go back. I thought it was a bit pricey compared with other restaurants offering fish fry dinners. ”